Senescence is actually not a biological default. It is an adaptation specifically selected for. Very simple organisms are biologically immortal by default.
As creatures become more complex, they become less malleable. Greater complexity means actualizing structure at the expense of potentiality. As structure and energy are interdependent, complexity is ultimately the accumulation of greater and greater energy and capacity for energy.
But for this to happen at the scale of the species or even the ecological superorganism, the compromise stumbled upon by evolution was for complex creatures to reproduce sexually and then expire so as to not take up resources needed by the next generation. Sex and death came into being together.
Adaptability, potentiality, is transferred to juvenile creatures with a window of malleability and high energy. That window is triggered to close by the introduction of extreme stressors or the loss of sufficient nutrition; One such trigger is, indeed, reproduction itself, at least if the environment is not ideal.
Such triggers shift the orientation of the organism towards a defensive withdrawal meant to protect the structure and complexity already built up when there does not seem to be hope for the “anabolic” adaptive window to reopen. This is aging.
Humans are a highly successful species partly because we have a very long youth which builds up a very complex, intelligent, high metabolism organism. But almost as importantly, we have a very long, slow senescent decline. This biological dynamic is why, extremely early in prehistory, we became capable of the ultimate adaptive tool, culture, which can be quickest defined as simply the generational transmission of knowledge. Other apes, elephants, and some whales and dolphins can do this too - also very complex and long-lifespan animals.
If we as a species were to decline and devolve, what that would look like is shorter childhoods with earlier puberties and then faster onset of obesity, depression & learned helplessness after adolescence, followed ultimately by dying younger from heart attacks or aggressive cancers.... all things that have become especially visible and unavoidable this century.
Our biological state is also reflected in our culture, and the culture of a declining species would reflect the organic drives most associated with dissolution and death: Compulsive sexuality and horror/adrenaline addiction. The popularity of mascot horror like FNAF with kids today is an extremely bad sign, yet almost nobody can see it for what it is.
The core problem with human devolution is not that this adaptive pathway exists, but that an artificial environment completely negates its adaptive value. Evolution is a blind god and, for some reason, is extremely susceptible to feedback loops. It has absolutely no mechanism for dealing with a creature that controls its own habitat. The adaptive pathways produced by evolution only work if the habitat is natural and subject to natural fluctuations and boom-bust cycles. A period of draught and famine will produce diminished creatures, but when those conditions end the next generation will regain most of what was lost, perhaps with adaptations that will make the next famine less stressful.
But in an artificial environment, preserving the prosperity and complexity of the habitat requires preserving the complexity and quality of the human capital running it, with no slip-ups and no breaks in the chain of succession for complex and delicate systems. Without embarking on an entirely new screed and tangent, let it suffice to say that our current civilization has utterly failed at preserving and cultivating human flourishing because it is optimized towards completely different and sometimes incompatible ends.
Senescence and death were an adaptation to enable a leap in complexity for life in its drive to accumulate energy and structure. Culture, and then the informational superorganism which has emerged from humanity’s capacity for culture, was another such adaptation and enabled another such leap. Some now expect artificial intelligence to be the next and greatest adaptation. If that is to be the case, then my point will be nullified. In that scenario, it is possible that there would be no bottom boundary on the extent to which homo sapiens could diminish into undifferentiated goo, contributing nothing at all to its own success or consciousness. It is equally possible such a scenario could lead to an idyllic nature preserve in which humans live out an AI-supervised simulacrum of the ancestral environment for which we are physiologically optimized.
But if neither these possibilities nor the possibility of utter extinction are to come about, if there is a future in which human intellect and agency continue to be necessary in any way, then it seems fair to say that we have reached the point of civilizational complexity at which death is no longer adaptive but is actually a liability to future progress. The same offloading of potentiality and adaptability which evolution once shunted onto juvenile organisms has today been shunted onto institutional super-organisms.
I will say that my point will also be nullified if it is imagined that the defeat of death is not equally the defeat of senescence. Immortal institutions ruled over by permanent geriatrics is a dystopian scenario on par with extinction. I propose instead that culture, science, civilization, as a superorganism, is finally close to the possibility of restoring and permanently preserving the adaptable, youthful, anabolic state for all individuals. Such an achievement is the highest possible earthly good for mankind. I say this even as someone who believes in the soul and reincarnation/afterlives: Senescence is a greater evil than death.
As horrifying as a world of permanent senescence and institutions run by immortal geriatrics would be, imagine instead a world in which scientists and artists have centuries to learn and refine their craft while also retaining the genius and vigor of their biological prime that whole time. I would argue that this is not only desirable but borderline necessary, as this current civilization has reached the point at which it has squeezed all the growth and innovation it possibly can out of its people to the point they can no longer even reproduce a next generation of the same size let alone the same competence level. The complete regeneration and re-humanization of the population is the only alternative to complete skynet automation, and both possibilities are operating on a ticking clock counting down the days until the universities, airlines, and nuclear reactors are all handed over to former iPad babies with multiple substance dependencies.


